Craglorn Interview with Rich Lambert

aetherian-mageTamriel Foundry is thrilled to feature an interview with Rich Lambert, Lead Content Designer for The Elder Scrolls Online and the mastermind behind the game’s first adventure zone of Craglorn and its trials of Hel Ra Citadel and the Aetherian Archive. This adventure zone will be the first major content expansion for ESO, adding an entire new zone as well as the hugely anticipated 12-player PvE trials.

Read on to check out our question and answer interview for some great insight into the design objectives of these trials and the challenges that players can expect to encounter within them.

 
Q: Rich, thank you so much for agreeing to answer some of our biggest questions about Craglorn and Trials for the Tamriel Foundry community. Could you start by sharing with everyone your role on the ESO team and how you’ve been involved with the creation of the game’s first adventure zone?

My pleasure! My name is Rich Lambert and I am the Lead Content Designer on ESO. In a nutshell, it’s my job to lead the content department and work with each of the teams to develop all the zones, dungeons, and Trials in the game.

Q: The Elder Scrolls Online seems to be pioneering its own unique slant on high-level group PvE, butwas there any specific encounter from a past MMO which inspired you to do something fun or cool during the development of a Craglorn Trial? What were some of your favorite group PvE memories from other games?

Craglorn as a concept is something that I’ve wanted to build since pretty much day one of ESO’s development. It harkens back to some of the old school games, (ugh I said ‘old school’) where grouping was really important for survival and stuff was hard. As a player, I definitely lean towards the “raiding” scene when I play MMOs. I raided in EQ and in WoW and a lot of my fondest PvE memories stem from those games. If I could only pick one moment, it would probably have to be from EQ and being the first guild to wake the Sleeper. I think I still have screenshots stashed away somewhere of that infamous day on The Rathe.

Q: We’ve learned that the first Trial in the game is the fortress of “Hel Ra Citadel”. However, we’ve also seen mention of the mysterious “Aetherian Archive.” Could you give a short spoiler-free explanation of these locales which set the flavor for what players may find there? Will both Trials be available when Craglorn launches, or is Hel Ra the focus of Craglorn and Aetherian Archive is for a later challenge?

Hel Ra Citidel once served as a forward base and training hall for the Yokudans when they invaded Tamriel long, long ago. The Trial itself is focused on the story of the Warrior Celestial and is more grounded in nature. On the other hand, the Aetherian Archive was once a research facility for a renegade group of mages who wished to study Tamriel without limits. The Trial here centers on the story of the Mage Celestial and is extremely high magic. Both of these Trials will be available when Craglorn launches.

craglorn-earth-atronach

One of the many formidable bosses which players will encounter in Craglorn’s trials.

Q: In a recent “Ask Us Anything”, you revealed that you could enter Craglorn stating at Veteran Rank 1. Are the Trials within Craglorn tied to the main story quest for that zone? Will players need to first progress through the group content of the adventure zone in order to access its Trials? If there is some sort of attunement or keying required, will everyone in the group need to have completed this step?

The Trials are tied to the zone in that they help to further flesh out the story of the Mage and the Warrior celestials, but you don’t have to do any kind of attunement or get a special key to enter them. You can just show up at the entrance, form up a group, and enter the Trial.

Q: One of the most frustrating aspects of current veteran dungeons for organized groups involves loot allocation. The most desirable drops from Veteran Dungeons are not able to be traded to other members of your party. Does loot allocation from Trial encounters function similarly to veteran dungeons where every participant receives their own loot? Does this equipment typically bind on acquire, or can Trial loot be traded amongst your group in some way? It would be really great to be able to give that awesome shield that drops to our tank who would actually use it!

Loot in Trials is handled the same way as in regular dungeons – where everyone gets their own roll on the loot table. The loot from the bosses, quest rewards, and leaderboard rankings are all BOP (bind on pickup/account).

Q: Will crafting play a large role for upgrading equipment earned in Craglorn? Can equipment earned in trails be upgraded using the same set of crafting tools used for other items in the game? For a number of reasons, legendary upgrade components are already very plentiful in the game’s economy. Have you considered alternative systems for allowing players to improve raid quality loot?

The loot that drops in the Trials can be upgraded just like loot from Veteran Dungeons or any other drop.

Craglorn features a haunting and shattered landscape.

Craglorn features a haunting and shattered landscape.

Q: The concept of “bannermen” as mentioned in your recent overview of Craglorn Trials sounds like an awesome way to make “trash” pulls more interesting. How many different varieties of bannermen are there in Craglorn’s Trials? Are the locations of bannermen ever randomized? Can you give any further details on how this system makes Craglorn’s Trials more challenging?

Bannermen are basically the group busters in the Trials. Each has its own unique set of challenges and when you get a couple of them together at once, the group is in for a world of hurt if they aren’t dealt with correctly. Each Trial has its own unique set of three Bannermen and they are generally found mixed within regular monsters.

Q: A large concern for groups who aspire to challenge for top times on the Trial leaderboards is that the PvP campaign bonuses provide a significant advantage for players who are members of a dominant campaign. An additional 250 health for every player combined with 6% increased critical hit chance can make a big difference for group performance. How are PvP bonuses handled in Craglorn? Are you worried that guilds will be forced to decide between competing in a balanced PvP campaign and challenging for PvE honors?

The PvP bonuses carry over into Trials, just like all other PvE activities. We are monitoring how this plays out, but we are seeing a lot more balance in the individual campaigns and it has started to become a lot more difficult to own everything and to get all the bonuses.

Q: It sounds like resurrection and death plays a key component in the Craglorn Trials. It was announced that parties will have a “soul reservoir” available for the duration of the Trial. Could you go into a bit more depth about how these resurrection mechanics will challenge groups in Trials?

Every time a player character dies and resurrects inside the Trial, a “soul” is removed from the soul reservoir. Once there are no more souls available, the fail state of the instance is reached and the group is forced to leave the instance. Once outside, the Trial can be reset and the group can renter and try again from the beginning. Currently each Trial is set to 36 resurrections, (which equates to 3 per player in the group) but we are still tweaking those numbers.

The mystical Aetherian Archive is the arcane enclave of the Celestial Mage.

The mysterious Aetherian Archive is the arcane enclave of the Celestial Mage.

Q: Is it possible to change your group configuration by substituting players in or out while a Trial is in-progress, or are the members of your group locked to the Trial until it is reset?

Yep you can change your group out as much as you want. It will not reset your soul reservoir though and is probably going to slow you down pretty significantly.

Q: For achievement hunters out there will Craglorn and its Trials have a full set of unlockable achievements for players to earn? Will the Undaunted have additional challenges for players to attempt in Trials similar to the existing “ok, you beat the boss, but can you do it the HARD way” achievements which exist for veteran dungeons? Are any unique titles earned by defeating the challenges in Hel Ra Citadel?

We will have a few achievements for the Trials at launch and have additional planned for the future. More on that soon!

Q: Do you have any tips or advice to share with the Tamriel Foundry community on how to prepare ourselves and our groups for the Craglorn Trials?

The 3 big things to remember:

  1. Death recap is insanely useful. Use it and strategize with your group when you die.
  2. Regular Trials monsters will generally give you clues to upcoming boss abilities, so pay attention.
  3. Deaths in Trials are big hits to your leaderboard time. If you are going for a top time, err on the side of staying alive over speed.

Good luck everyone and I hope you all enjoy Craglorn and its Trials!

I would like to, once again, express our sincere thanks to Rich Lambert for taking the time to address some of our questions about Craglorn and its trials. I hope you have found these questions and answers interesting. I’m interested to see how some of our concerns regarding loot allocation and PvP campaign bonuses end up affecting the way groups approach trials in ESO. The intended level of difficulty for Craglorn’s trials sounds awesome, and I can’t wait to start progressing through them once patch 1.1 reaches the live servers. Let us know what you think about Craglorn and Rich’s insight into its challenges in the comment section below!

40 responses to “Craglorn Interview with Rich Lambert”

  1. Member Avatar
    okunhardt

    Expert

    Total Posts: 320

    Dunmer Dragonknight

    Craglorn looks really fun, but I will not be playing it for a little while.

  2. Profile Photo
    shadesofkin

    Journeyman

    Total Posts: 72

    Imperial Dragonknight

    The Keepers

    I’m extremely excited for Craglorn and the Trials. This is looking to be a great bit of content upcoming.

  3. Profile Photo
    Mewie

    Scamp

    Total Posts: 7

    Breton Templar

    Awesome interview. Looking forward to exploring Craglorn!

  4. Profile Photo
    OriharaIzaya

    Adept

    Total Posts: 175

    Imperial Sorcerer

    Very insightful and some good information. Thanks for taking the time to do this interview!

    ”I was born 87 years ago. For 65 years I’ve ruled as Tamriel’s Emperor. But for all these years I have never been the ruler of my own dreams. I have seen the Gates of Oblivion, beyond which no waking eye may see. Behold, in Darkness a Doom sweeps the land. This is the 27th of Last Seed; the Year of Akatosh 433. These are the closing days of the 3rd Era, and the final hours of my life.”

     

     

  5. Profile Photo
    Morkulth

    Expert

    Total Posts: 425

    Altmer Sorcerer

    Entropy Rising

    Not at all excited about pvp bonuses in craglorn. This is just going to lead to the top end PvE guilds all filling out a campaign their alliance is winning and has perma emp on.

  6. Profile Photo
    Pollination-Technician

    Master

    Total Posts: 513

    Altmer Sorcerer

    Morkulth said on May 9, 2014 :

    Not at all excited about pvp bonuses in craglorn. This is just going to lead to the top end PvE guilds all filling out a campaign their alliance is winning and has perma emp on.

    I feel the same way. I don’t really understand the point of getting PvP buffs in PvE, I thought it was a glitch until now.

    Trust not the words of a poet, as he is born to seduce. Yet for poetry to seize the heart, it must ring with the chimes of truth.

    Contrary to popular belief, ESO pvp battles are not fought in Cyrodiil. They are fought on online forums by calling for any and everything that kills you to be nerfed.

     

    Subscription Canceled

  7. Profile Photo
    Phazius

    Master

    Total Posts: 833

    Dunmer Dragonknight

    Entropy Rising

    Morkulth said on May 9, 2014 :

    Not at all excited about pvp bonuses in craglorn. This is just going to lead to the top end PvE guilds all filling out a campaign their alliance is winning and has perma emp on.

    Yup, the bonuses working in Trials will re-unbalance the campaigns.

    I feel like most of the devs have very little interview experience, not a whole lot of detail here :P

  8. Profile Photo
    Azengard

    Adept

    Total Posts: 111

    Nord Dragonknight

    With this I’m even more hurried to get VR10!!!

  9. Profile Photo
    Moonraker

    Expert

    Total Posts: 351

    Breton Sorcerer

    Phazius said on May 9, 2014 :

    Morkulth said on May 9, 2014 :

    Not at all excited about pvp bonuses in craglorn. This is just going to lead to the top end PvE guilds all filling out a campaign their alliance is winning and has perma emp on.

    Yup, the bonuses working in Trials will re-unbalance the campaigns.

    I feel like most of the devs have very little interview experience, not a whole lot of detail here

    Agreed. Other interviews with Paul Sage for example are a lot more fleshed out. This was almost like a CS response on the forum. It is a shame as these seem to be their way of getting developer communication out to the players but this really doesn’t tell us anything in any depth.

    In fact rereading it the responses are poor. Short to the point of curt, lacking detail and even a sense of enthusiasm. If these are to be the main point of contact with developers to the community they need to open up and enter in some form of dialogue even if it is coached to manage expectation.

  10. Profile Photo
    Moonraker

    Expert

    Total Posts: 351

    Breton Sorcerer

    This:

    Every time a player character dies and resurrects inside the Trial, a “soul” is removed from the soul reservoir. Once there are no more souls available, the fail state of the instance is reached and the group is forced to leave the instance. Once outside, the Trial can be reset and the group can renter and try again from the beginning. Currently each Trial is set to 36 resurrections, (which equates to 3 per player in the group) but we are still tweaking those numbers.

    Differences pretty fundamentally with what Paul Sage posted a few days ago in his MMORPG interview;

    The new Trials are challenging instances designed for groups of 12 players. These groups will move through the zone to see the sights and fight various monsters along the way. The catch is that group members have a limited number of times they can resurrect each week. Right now Trials allow for 60 resurrections, or 5 per player. The rewards for completing a Trial also change each week, and the best completion times are tracked on a public leaderboard.

    source

    That’s almost half the resurrections. Granted they both say to be tweaked but that’s a big difference.

    The MMORPG article also said it was a weekly limit BUT that is not what he says in the actual podcast so assume it’s not accurate.

    One aspect that was not mentioned which is maybe more related to more casual players is that although the leader board etc. and Trial timed additional loot is linked to a time critical run, it is also possible to take your time and complete the Trial without worrying about the time and still get loot and to complete the Trial. At least that is how it seemed to work from previous info.

  11. Profile Photo
    Waltaro

    Apprentice

    Total Posts: 38

    Khajiit Nightblade

    Can’t wait for this to come out! 12-player trials and a whole new area to explore with a group ^^

  12. Profile Photo
    Jhaankreii

    Apprentice

    Total Posts: 26

    Breton Templar

    Good interview. Can’t wait for this to come out.

    Armored FIST is currently recruiting Veteran players for Trials.  Please contact us here.

  13. Profile Photo
    Fintan

    Scamp

    Total Posts: 3

    Imperial Templar

    Tamriel’s Finest

    I have to pick up my pace!!! When does this release?

    Dark ANCHORS, ColdHARBOUR, I wonder if Molag Bal is just a demonic pirate.

  14. Member Avatar
    Lewis Clamp

    Adept

    Total Posts: 109

    Orc Dragonknight

    The Order of the Ebony Lion

    Its going to be epic to play!

  15. Profile Photo
    Witness

    Expert

    Total Posts: 428

    Altmer Dragonknight

    Vigil Stellarum

    I for one am getting really annoyed!

    Just look at the twitter wall for ESO its full of Craglorn coming, Craglorn Screens , Craglorn this, Craglorn that…..

    NO RELEASE DATE OR ETA!!!

    This leads me to become worried as I sense that most players would unsub after the first month of craglorns release and wait for more content, ESO sense this and so drag this out for players who ATM have nothing to do at the end game.

    So I fear they will wait one more month to release to force players into at least 2 months of subscription to run the Trials…

     

    Meaning we could still have another month to wait before figuring out how to best max out stats with v12 gear etc….

    VERY ANNOYING!

    Heed the Call!
    Join us to conquer the world of the Elder Scrolls
    Take advantage of our Mature & Experienced Players

  16. Profile Photo
    Xeen

    Expert

    Total Posts: 453

    Altmer Dragonknight

    Quote:

    Q: Do you have any tips or advice to share with the Tamriel Foundry community on how to prepare ourselves and our groups for the Craglorn Trials?

    The 3 big things to remember:

    1. Death recap is insanely useful. Use it and strategize with your group when you die.
    2. Regular Trials monsters will generally give you clues to upcoming boss abilities, so pay attention.
    3. Deaths in Trials are big hits to your leaderboard time. If you are going for a top time, err on the side of staying alive over Speed.

    Guys, you know how that question and answer game works ?

    Vollendet in Wahnfried, ich sage nichts weiter.

  17. Profile Photo
    Mystborn

    Master

    Total Posts: 889

    Breton Templar

    Entropy Rising

    Moonraker said on May 9, 2014 :

    This:

    Every time a player character dies and resurrects inside the Trial, a “soul” is removed from the soul reservoir. Once there are no more souls available, the fail state of the instance is reached and the group is forced to leave the instance. Once outside, the Trial can be reset and the group can renter and try again from the beginning. Currently each Trial is set to 36 resurrections, (which equates to 3 per player in the group) but we are still tweaking those numbers.

    Differences pretty fundamentally with what Paul Sage posted a few days ago in his MMORPG interview;

    The new Trials are challenging instances designed for groups of 12 players. These groups will move through the zone to see the sights and fight various monsters along the way. The catch is that group members have a limited number of times they can resurrect each week. Right now Trials allow for 60 resurrections, or 5 per player. The rewards for completing a Trial also change each week, and the best completion times are tracked on a public leaderboard.

    source

    That’s almost half the resurrections. Granted they both say to be tweaked but that’s a big difference.

    The MMORPG article also said it was a weekly limit BUT that is not what he says in the actual podcast so assume it’s not accurate.

    One aspect that was not mentioned which is maybe more related to more casual players is that although the leader board etc. and Trial timed additional loot is linked to a time critical run, it is also possible to take your time and complete the Trial without worrying about the time and still get loot and to complete the Trial. At least that is how it seemed to work from previous info.

    There were 60 souls when they first put trials on the PTS but they recently patched to reduce to 36 souls.

  18. Member Avatar
    ubiach

    Apprentice

    Total Posts: 47

    Dunmer Dragonknight

    i hate the loot system but well we have to go with it

  19. Profile Photo
    RagnarLodbrok

    Expert

    Total Posts: 296

    Orc Templar

    yawwwwn still waiting for a date… considering some main questlines are still bugged. might wanna make the pts open to the public…sounds like zos could use as many hands as possible. they were not ready at launch and have obviously been playing catchup ever since.

    so regardless of the 4-6 week content patch timeline which i highly doubt they are gonna be able to catch up with. i really doubt the questing/mechanics are gonna work all that well or smoothly. sure most of it will probably work. but who wants to hop in craglorn and run into bugs or glitches that prevent progress? whether trial or overland content. dont get your expectations to high. once i got tired of cyrodil and questing i realized there really is not much else to do besides farm crafting mats…which is fun herer and there dont want to play that everyday.

    i never bought game time after first free month as i saw this coming. hopefully others did aswell and wait for craglorn to resub, unless of course they are perfectly content with what gameplay options are currently available.

    ragnar

  20. Member Avatar
    exhuman

    Novice

    Total Posts: 10

    Witness said on May 10, 2014 :

    I for one am getting really annoyed!

    Just look at the twitter wall for ESO its full of Craglorn coming, Craglorn Screens , Craglorn this, Craglorn that…..

    NO RELEASE DATE OR ETA!!!

    This leads me to become worried as I sense that most players would unsub after the first month of craglorns release and wait for more content, ESO sense this and so drag this out for players who ATM have nothing to do at the end game.

    So I fear they will wait one more month to release to force players into at least 2 months of subscription to run the Trials…

    Meaning we could still have another month to wait before figuring out how to best max out stats with v12 gear etc….

    VERY ANNOYING!

     

    This game was released one month ago and there are people that have nothing to do at the moment? how is that even possible?

    And lets say its possible, its not normal. You should level in real life also at the same time :D

     

Comment On: “Craglorn Interview with Rich Lambert”

You are not currently logged in. You must log in before commenting.